Historic Sag Harbor Property with Prohibition Roots Hits the Market

September 10, 2025 - 17:58

The Sag Harbor spread, located at 330 Main St., has a storied past that intertwines with the vibrant history of the area. Once the residence of renowned composer Marvin Hamlisch, this property is not only notable for its artistic connections but also for its intriguing history as a speakeasy during Prohibition.

The house, with its charming architecture, reflects the unique character of Sag Harbor, a village known for its rich maritime heritage and artistic community. The property has seen countless gatherings and celebrations, echoing the lively spirit of the Roaring Twenties when it served as a hidden venue for revelers seeking a taste of forbidden spirits.

Now on the market, this home presents a rare opportunity for buyers looking to own a piece of history. With its blend of artistic legacy and historical significance, the property is expected to attract interest from both history enthusiasts and those seeking a luxurious retreat in the Hamptons. As it stands, the home is a testament to the vibrant cultural tapestry of the region, promising to inspire its next owners just as it did Hamlisch and his guests.